Walk-In Shower or Bathtub? A Key Decision in NJ Bathroom Remodels
When planning a bathroom remodel in New Jersey, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to install a walk-in shower or a bathtub. It’s a choice that comes up often with our clients, and for good reason—it impacts your comfort, daily routine, and even your home’s resale value.
Over the years, we’ve helped many NJ homeowners weigh the pros and cons, factoring in everything from lifestyle needs to local market trends. The right answer isn’t the same for everyone, but with the right insights, you can make a decision that fits your home and how you actually live.
Why It Matters More Than You Might Think
This decision isn’t just about aesthetics. It shapes how your bathroom functions every day and how potential buyers see your home down the line. In New Jersey’s competitive real estate market, thoughtful bathroom upgrades tend to bring a solid return—especially when they’re tailored to the neighborhood and buyer expectations.
Before diving into layout options, take a minute to consider a few key points:
- How do you use your bathroom now—and how might that change in a few years?
- Are you remodeling for yourself, or with resale in mind?
- How much space do you really have to work with?
Let’s break it all down.
Why Walk-In Showers Are So Popular in NJ Homes
Modern Style
Walk-in showers give bathrooms a clean, open look that feels fresh and modern. They can make even smaller bathrooms feel more spacious, especially with the right tile and glasswork. We’ve created beautiful, tiled walk-ins for NJ homes that have become true focal points.
Accessibility
If you’re thinking long term, walk-in showers are a smart move. With low or no thresholds, they’re easier to access and safer for anyone with mobility concerns. We’ve installed many accessible showers that combine function with high-end finishes.
Easy to Clean
With fewer hard-to-reach spots, walk-in showers are typically easier to maintain than tubs. High-quality tile and proper sealing go a long way in keeping your shower looking great with less effort.
Room to Customize
From rain heads to body sprays and built-in niches, walk-in showers offer endless customization. We love working with clients to pick tile layouts and features that reflect their style and make the space feel personalized.
When a Bathtub Still Makes the Most Sense
Perfect for Families
For households with young kids, a bathtub often just makes life easier. Bath time is part of the nightly routine, and a tub is a must-have for many families. We can create tub surrounds that are both kid-friendly and visually appealing.
A Space to Unwind
For those who love to soak and relax, a bathtub is still hard to beat. Many of our clients working stressful jobs in NJ ask for a deep soaking tub where they can decompress after a long day.
Resale-Friendly
Many buyers—especially families—expect to see at least one bathtub in a home. In NJ neighborhoods with younger homeowners or growing families, having no tub at all could be a drawback when you go to sell.
Versatile Styles
From classic built-ins to freestanding centerpieces, tubs come in a wide range of styles. Pair them with custom tile and thoughtful lighting, and they become standout features in any bathroom remodel.
Got the Space? Let’s Talk Layout
Walk-In Shower Dimensions
The sweet spot for a walk-in shower starts at around 36″ x 36″, though going a bit larger—like 42″ x 42″ or more—can make a big difference in comfort. We’re used to maximizing every inch in tight NJ homes to give clients that open, spa-like feel even when space is limited.
Bathtub Footprint
A standard tub usually takes up about 30″ x 60″, but freestanding or soaking tubs need more clearance. That space can be a big commitment, especially in smaller or older homes.
Smart Solutions for Small Bathrooms
In older NJ houses, bathrooms often come with tight layouts. We’ve handled plenty of remodels where creative planning made all the difference—like corner tubs, compact soaking tubs, or unique shower-tub layouts.
Code Compliance
Local NJ codes play a role too, especially with minimum dimensions for fixtures and proper clearances. That’s why working with experienced pros matters. We’ll help you meet all the requirements while still achieving the look and feel you want.
Budget Breakdown: What Costs What?
Upfront Costs
Bathtubs generally cost less than custom walk-in showers. That said, luxury tubs or added features like jets can get pricey fast. The same goes for tiled showers with specialty materials or high-end fixtures.
Long-Term Value
Walk-in showers often use less water and are simpler to maintain, which can help you save money over time. With fewer mechanical parts, there’s also less that can break down.
Upgrade Opportunities
Whether you go for a shower or a tub, some upgrades really boost value. Frameless glass, premium tiles, or heated flooring can take your bathroom to the next level. We help NJ homeowners choose materials that feel luxurious without blowing the budget.
Return on Investment
Both options can add serious value to your home—if the job is done right. Quality workmanship and smart design choices are what make the difference in how your remodel pays off down the line.
What’s Trending Right Now in NJ Bathrooms?
Showers
Curbless, doorless showers are gaining steam across New Jersey. Large-format tiles, built-in benches, and statement tile walls are popular choices, especially in primary bathrooms.
Tubs
Freestanding tubs—especially with a minimalist or Japanese-inspired design—are still in demand. They look great and don’t require a huge footprint if chosen carefully.
Tile Trends
Porcelain tiles that look like natural stone are big right now. They give the luxury feel of marble or travertine, but with easier upkeep. Wood-look tiles are another favorite, offering warmth without the worry of moisture damage.
Tech Upgrades
Smart showers, mood lighting, built-in Bluetooth speakers, and warming drawers are just a few of the features NJ homeowners are starting to include in their bathroom remodels.
Can You Have Both? Yes, You Can.
Shower-Tub Combos That Work
Forget the old fiberglass combos—today’s designs can blend the benefits of both a tub and shower in a way that feels upscale. Think frameless panels, floating shelves, and high-end fixtures.
Wet Room Style
This approach waterproofs the whole space, making it possible to install a walk-in shower and freestanding tub in one cohesive layout. It takes more planning and craftsmanship, but the result is stunning.
Compact Yet Comfortable
Japanese soaking tubs paired with overhead showers are ideal for tight NJ bathrooms. They save space while still delivering a relaxing soak when you need it.
Custom Layouts
Every home is different. We’ve helped NJ clients turn unusual bathroom shapes into beautiful, practical spaces with solutions tailored to their needs.
Making Your Final Decision: A Simple Process
- Think About Your Routine
Do you take fast showers, or do you love a long soak on the weekends? Let your habits guide the choice. - Consider the Long Term
Are you planning to sell in the next few years, or is this your forever home? Your answer helps set the direction. - Measure Everything
Don’t guess—get accurate dimensions. We can help you visualize options before making a final decision. - Talk to a Pro
Every home and homeowner is different. Our team at Kasco Tile LLC offers consultations to help you weigh your priorities and design a space that really works.
Ready to Take the Next Step?
Whether you’re team tub, team shower, or want a bit of both, we’re here to help you make a smart, stylish choice. At Kasco Tile LLC, we bring years of experience and a deep understanding of what New Jersey homeowners need from their bathrooms.
Let’s design a space that suits your life—and adds real value to your home.
Reach out for a free consultation today. Let’s make your bathroom remodel in NJ everything it should be.